|
CNC Router Helps Violin Teacher Manufacture Violins in Spare Time
A computer numerical control (CNC) router that
produces high accuracy wood components with minimal operator
attention has helped a violin instructor get into the violin
manufacturing business in his spare time. Jesse Newcomer, who runs
the Suzuki violin teaching program in Alexandria, Louisiana, and a
violin dealership, produces 60 violins per year targeted at high
school and college students that sell for between $2500 and $3500
retail. The CNC router produces nearly all of the parts for the
violins to very high levels of accuracy in Newcomer’s garage,
while he is selling, teaching or relaxing and occasionally observing
it through a video monitor.
Jesse Newcomer has been playing violin since he was 5 years
old. He earned a Master of Church Music with an emphasis in violin
from the New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary. He was the first
graduate from that institution to receive a music degree with any
emphasis besides voice. He served as music director or minister of
music at a number of churches in the south. Just prior to opening
his violin dealership, he served as orchestra director for a church
with a full orchestra that included violins, cello, viola,
clarinets, trumpets, trombones and percussions, all played by
volunteers. This orchestra performed traditional hymns and anthems,
more and more of which are being scored for orchestra, as well as
oratorios such as Handel’s Messiah.
Opening
dealership
Several years ago,
Newcomer heard that the Suzuki program in Alexandria was for sale
and decided that it would be the perfect opportunity to spend more
time on his first love, teaching and playing violin. He purchased
the program and also opened a violin dealership and repair shop.
Newcomer’s friendship with a man in a nearby town that owned a
machine shop got him to thinking: why can’t I build my own
violins? His friend pointed out that CNC machining centers would
produce wooden components to a tolerance levels that would make it
possible to produce an outstanding violin without necessarily
possessing the woodworking skills of a master craftsman. The problem
with these machines is that they are so expensive, typically
starting at around $50,000 not including CNC programming software,
that they would be difficult for someone producing violins to
afford.
Then, one day his friend received
a brochure for a CNC router that provides the same accuracy and
level of automation as conventional CNC machining centers,
but it was designed for lighter duty machining such as cutting wood,
plastics, nonferrous materials and taking light cuts in nonferrous
metals. Newcomer ended up
purchasing that machine, the Techno Series III from Techno-Isel, New
Hyde Park, New York. The price was less than $19,000 and included
CNC programming software. Its working area of 24 inches by 36
inches with a Z-axis height of 6 inches is considerably larger than
required for producing violins.
The
Techno-Isel router produces all of the parts needed to make a violin
in about 100 hours, compared to the 350 to 400 hours that would be
required to make the same parts by hand
Designing
jigs
Newcomer was familiar
with violin manufacturing, but had never built one completely from
scratch before so he enlisted Mark Lisle, a violin maker in Houston,
to build a violin for him and worked with him from start to finish
on the project. The two worked so well together on this project that
they decided to form a violin-producing partnership, Newcomer &
Lisle Violins. After this experience, Newcomer had no difficulty in
designing the components needed to build the violin using the CNC
programming software. Next, he designed the jigs needed to hold the
components on the router while they were being machined. Each of the
jigs is built from two pieces of wood with the top piece cut out so
that it cradles that component that is being machined. The bottom
piece, which attaches to the table of the Techno machine, has holes
cut in it that are attached to plastic tubes running to a suction
pump that holds the piece onto the jig.
Newcomer
set the machine up in his garage. His house is connected to his
store so he was able to rig video monitors in both places that allow
him to observe the machine while he is working or relaxing.
Actually, the machine needs little attention. It produces all of the
parts needed to make a violin in about 100 hours, compared to the
350 to 400 hours that would be required to make the same parts by
hand. In addition, the CNC
machine produces the parts to much higher levels of accuracy than
can be achieved by hand. The machine's 0.0004 inch resolution
and repeatability and 0.003 inch absolute accuracy ensure that each
violin component is identical, maintaining the excellent sound that
Newcomer and Lisle designed into the instruments.
Excellent accuracy
The Techno machine's accuracy is the result of several
features inherent to the table, such as the use of ball screws and
servo motors. For example, anti-backlash ball screws permit
play-free motion that makes it possible to produce accurate circles
and inlays. The ballscrews have excellent power transmission due to
the rolling ball contact between the nut and screw. This rolling
contact also ensures longer life and greater rigidity during the
life of the system because of the reduced wear as compared to ACME
screws and nuts, which have a sliding friction contact.
The
next issue that Newcomer faced was that he didn’t have time to
assemble more than an occasional violin. Fortunately, his partner
Lisle knew a violin maker in China. This person agreed to assemble
the pieces produced by Newcomer. This arrangement made it possible
for Newcomer to begin volume production. The table of the Techno
machine is large enough to mount all of the jigs needed to produce a
violin. So, Newcomer sets the machine up to run unattended while he
goes about his business, just keeping an eye out in case the bit
needs changing. He typically produces batches of 20 that he can
complete in a month without seriously distracting him from his other
businesses. The only parts that Newcomer doesn’t produce on the
Techno machine are the ribs that go inside the case. He makes these
on a hand router because they are so geometrically simple.
Reliable
operation
In
several years of operation, Newcomer has had no problems with the
Techno machine. This is partly due to the strength and rigidity of
the table, which is constructed from extruded aluminum profiles that
provide easy clamping capability. The machine also has four ground
and hardened steel shafts and eight recirculating bearings in each
axis. This shaft and bearing system produces very smooth play-free
motion and an extremely rigid system that produces high-quality
cuts.
Newcomer sells the
violins through his own shop and also through other violin dealers
in the South. The target market is exceptionally talented high
school and college students. Newcomer's violins are known for their
strong, rich sound and outstanding detail and workmanship. Their characteristics are
richness, warmth, softness of timbre, and depth. Newcomer is able to
provide these qualities in every instrument its makes because the
CNC router that it uses to produce the parts provides much higher
accuracy that traditional woodworking methods. At the same
time, the fact that the Techno machine is relatively inexpensive and
runs virtually unattended makes it possible for Newcomer to provide
promising younger players with an outstanding hand-built instrument
at a fraction of the cost of comparable quality instruments. All in
all, the new machine has proven to be the perfect way to get into a
business that’s both fun and profitable without spending an arm
and a leg or committing a major amount of time.
|